Advertisement
hypnobirthing.com/ - This method teaches self-hypnosis, guided imagery and breathing techniques to bring about a natural birth.
bradleybirth.com/ - Husband coached child birthing.
I spoke to my doctor yesterday and she had no experience with HypnoBirthing, but she said that her experience with the Bradley Method was not good. She said that it was very restrictive and that her patients signed a contract saying that they would not take any drugs during their birth.
That seems very pushy to me. While I would prefer a natural birth I don't want to feel guilty for asking for an epidural if the pain is too intense.
What are your experiences with the two methods and what do you think works better....any pros and cons or advice would be helpful.
bradleybirth.com/ - Husband coached child birthing.
I spoke to my doctor yesterday and she had no experience with HypnoBirthing, but she said that her experience with the Bradley Method was not good. She said that it was very restrictive and that her patients signed a contract saying that they would not take any drugs during their birth.
That seems very pushy to me. While I would prefer a natural birth I don't want to feel guilty for asking for an epidural if the pain is too intense.
What are your experiences with the two methods and what do you think works better....any pros and cons or advice would be helpful.
Advertisement
Advertisement
-
Re: The Bradley Method vs. HypnoBirthing
Thu, September 27, 2007 - 12:48 PMi took a hypnobirth class, although i wound up with a scheduled c-section (due to a huge head on my son, and i mean HUGE). the class was great, and i have complete confidence that it would have helped. even with the c-section, my son and i were very relaxed, and had a really positive birth experience. they say that hypnobirth babies are calmer, easier to soothe, and less likely to cry. dunno if it's true, but my boy is a very easygoing, mellow kid. but he is 2, so we do get occasional tantrums :) it's like dealing with a different kid.
i have no personal experience with the bradley method, but my doctor said she didn't like it, because not only is it a very long course of classes (which requires a longer-term commitment than most other classes), but also, the program doesn't really help reduce pain, it just tells you to accept the pain. she said that really doesn't help a whole lot of people in the delivery room. -
-
Re: The Bradley Method vs. HypnoBirthing
Thu, September 27, 2007 - 12:56 PMI don't have experience with either method, but I agree with you, Lesley that making patients sign a contract regarding no drugs IS pushy. I prefer naturual births as well and was fortunate to have them. (I was not in labour as long as some women.) But, I would never consider signing a contract like that. -
-
Re: The Bradley Method vs. HypnoBirthing
Thu, September 27, 2007 - 3:33 PM
Hi, I live in the Uk and bought these UK produced hypnotherapy cds..if you click on the link you can read about them. I don't know if it'll work for me yet or if it will be as good as attending classes which I might do later on. I'll let you all know later:)
It sounds like signing a contract to say you won't take pain killers with the Bradley system is all about your intent to "accept" the pain and make a commitment to yourself that you will, so signing the contract is almost a ritual. I'm sure you can just go back on it and take drugs anyway. It does sound like they don't offer viable strategies for managing the pain so why does the course take long? Mybe theres more to it..
Heres the link
www.natalhypnotherapy.co.uk/
-
-
-
Re: The Bradley Method vs. HypnoBirthing
Sat, October 6, 2007 - 9:37 PMI did the Bradley Method with both my children and have to say it was a mixed blessing in both cases. The theories are sound enough, it seems logical that women have been giving birth without any medical assistance for thousands of years, and yet.....
My first baby I did completely natural childbirth and the labor lasted 2 and a half days ( 8 hours hard labor) and my second was in a hospital and I saw the rotation of nurses about 3 times ("Betty, how's it going? How's that golf game improving?" "Jane, my big handed nurse of love... could you get someone else to check my dilation? No offense") That labor was induced and even with the mild drug "stayitol" which doesn't work for beans, it took 3 days. I am sure I am a freak of nature here, but even though both babies were very healthy, i felt a little cheated that I couldn't achieve this nirvanic state of mind that Bradley talked about. The films they show exhibit women basically hiccuping and giggling and then in 2 relaxing seconds of pushing.....pop out their little darling!!! I am just saying that doing whatever you need to do to feel successful is what you should do. The Bradley Method isn't that militaristic about signing a contract (at least in my two experiences) but they do propose a drug free birth. Anyone should prepare for the unexpected and have a plan b- z if your first plan doesn't work. Good Luck. And listen to your own voice.
-
Re: The Bradley Method vs. HypnoBirthing
Tue, October 9, 2007 - 10:24 PMI'm a huge fan of hypnobirthing. The deep relaxation practice is great during pregnancy, so you benefit even if you don't need it for labor! As a doula, I encourage everyone to look into it. The midwife who taught the class I took was very nonjudgemental about meds - she said "If you need it, you need it. It doesn't mean you've done anything wrong, just that your baby is probably very big, or in a bad position." Mine was a homebirth, so the drugs weren't an option, but honestly the hypnobirthing worked so well I didn't miss them.
-
Re: The Bradley Method vs. HypnoBirthing
Wed, October 10, 2007 - 6:07 AMIn the end, The baby comes *smile*...
With my two, I had Precipitous Back Labour...I went from 0 effacement, not dropped, no dilation, to a baby in less than 4 hours. It hurts. I tried to meditate to self hypnotize, but it was not happening because precipitous labour doesnt give you a chance to even breathe. In the end both babies needed epidurals, and I STILL felt them...
You just never can tell what the little darlings are going to do...or what birth process is going to be coming your way...you just trust your body to tell you what you need, and what you can handle..
Don't feel guilty for asking for drugs if you need them...both mine I needed drugs with, and they are beautiful happy children.... -
-
Re: The Bradley Method vs. HypnoBirthing
Wed, October 10, 2007 - 1:01 PMabsolutely.
healthy mom + healthy baby = good birth
-
-
Re: The Bradley Method vs. HypnoBirthing
Thu, October 11, 2007 - 8:56 PMBirthdance is another choice. Bellydance that baby out Mama.
Google Birthdance.
-
Re: The Bradley Method vs. HypnoBirthing
Fri, October 12, 2007 - 11:41 AMI took a Bradley class but ended up having to have labor induced two week before due date because I was measuring small for term (had actually shrunk a little and sonogram showed low amniotic fluid, so midwives were a concerned about letting me carry longer).
From the time I was given Cervadil (to soften the cervix in preparation for induction) to the time my daughter was born was 22 hours I believe. I ended up getting an epidural because after 20 hours I was only 4cm dilated (or was it 2? I can't remember now...all I know is it was *not* where it needed to be for having labored so long). My body just refused to relax (it's just hard to do when you're on Pitocin - I highly recommend avoiding induction as fervently as you possibly can), probably because I had that stupid monitor on and couldn't get up and walk around. Anyway, as soon as I had the epidural I fell asleep - everyone found that funny - for about an hour and half and then it was time to push. Took 15 minutes and I had a beautiful little girl!
Annnnyway, my Bradley teacher *never* made us sign anything about not taking drugs at birth. As a matter of fact, she was very supportive and agreed all through the class that it's better to avoid drugs during labor as best you can, but she always also pointed out that if it becomes necessary, not to feel guilty about it. Her philosophy is that you should do everything you can to avoid induction, because that's where you get into a slippery slope of ending up with an epidural....exactly like I did. The concept is, when you're induced, you have to have an IV and a monitor, and when you have the monitor, you can't get up and move around - when you can't get up and move around, you can't get into the most comfortable position for yourself and thus you experience a great deal more discomfort, you can't relax, and you end up having to have the epidural. My case was a textbook example of this. The funny part is, after talking to my mother, I discovered that she had low amniotic fluid with all three of us. So in hindsight I probably should have talked the midwives and doc into letting me go another week before acquiescing to induction.
So I wouldn't take your doc's word for it. I really liked the Bradley Method because it was well-rounded; covering diet, exercise, relaxation and breathing techniques. Find a teacher and ask for references, ask for her method of teaching and you'll be able to gather whether she (or he I guess) is militant or flexible. As with anything else, I'm sure there are teachers at both ends of the spectrum.
As for Hypnobirthing....can't say I've had any experience with it, though I have heard good things about it.
:)
Ahlam
-
Re: The Bradley Method vs. HypnoBirthing
Sun, October 14, 2007 - 10:08 PMRead Pushed: The Painful Truth About Childbirth and Modern Maternity Care by Jennifer Block
REALLY, it was all the information I had wished I had when I gave birth
I did a mixture of Birthing from Within and Hypnobirthing...we took childbirth classes from a doula www.alaboroflove.org/mustrea...cle.html (highly recommend reading the articles just to get a better idea what to ask doctors) and had a different doula at our birth. Highly recommend a doula because honey your brain GOES during labor and husbands are worried about you in such pain. Having a confident calm person who knows how to translate between you and the doc (making sure the doc knows what you wanted and telling you in lay mens terms what the hell they are jabbering about during the nurse shift change when you have been pushing for an hour was a life saver). My Hypnobirthing came in the form of chanting Om Nama Shiva Ya which I had learned when I was a little girl and my mom was a psychologist studying meditation methods. It popped out as soon as my first big contraction hit and neither my doula nor doctor had ever seen anything like it. I chanted through every contraction for a day and a half. Made me not think about the contraction, could verbalize my pain and had something to do other than grunt and yell. It really soothed me the whole time. Not sure how this would translate to someone that doesn't have this embedded in their head. On iTunes I found a couple of straight chants without the floofy new age stuff on them. Look up Om Nama Shivaya
Swami Vagishanda Saraswati- get both the slow and fast chant, you will need the fast chant when you are in transition
Rattan Mohan Sharma- has a bit more rhythm to it which will help you with your candance -
-
Re: The Bradley Method vs. HypnoBirthing
Mon, October 15, 2007 - 2:55 PMThat's crazy, Ziah... I also did a mix of Birthing from Within and Hypnobirthing- you and I didn't even talk about that. my doula recommended the first and I found the second searching for the first online. I liked doing art projects to express and process the feelings and ideas about giving birth, as BFW suggested. (I also read Girlfriend's Guide to Pregnancy, which was hilarious and helpful in many ways, but you do have to ignore quite a bit if you're planning a natural birth).
My doula was especially great about handling the pushy nurse who wouldn't stop (initially) bugging me about pain medication. (after I put up the 'drug free labor in progress, please do not offer drugs or epidural, thank you for your confidence and support' sign [words directly from BFW], apparently she stopped asking. I say apparently because initially I didn''t even remember her asking... yes, your mind goes and you forget some things later. Not all, but some. My midwife and doulas (one was apprenticing and was my massage therapist through my pregnancy) called my husband a natural doula, moving quickly and silently to take care of things often before I knew I needed them.
I did a variety of things with the contractions- often, I'd move/dance (lots of circles and figure eights) through them, making whatever loud, deep noises felt like coming out of my throat. I was in a variety of different positions- had plenty of time to try them since Baby came 33 or so hours after labor started. I used the ball, a chair, the birthing chair, the bathroom counter (boy were the contrations intense when going to the bathroom!), and tried sleeping a bit between contractions after the first day. also was in the whirl pool tub a while. My doula was also my pre natal yoga teacher and she took me through some yoga series and focused breathing. one of the most amazing parts of labor was late in the process when I started chanting (also on my own, spontaneously happened) and my doulas and sister joined in. I used chants I learned from Sonia Sumar from the Yoga for the Special Child program- Om Shanti Om Shanti Om Shanti Om... repeated in several different ways; same for Hari Om Hari Om Hari Hari Hari OM... Om Joyti Om Joyti Om Joyti Om. I also had a picture of Ganesh and some of my birth art to focus on. All this was what made my doula say we freaked the staff. :) (she also said it was the most beautiful birth she'd ever been to... I felt it was an amazing, intense experience, and yes, beautiful despite all the hard work.)
I was able to get through more than 32 or so hours of labor without pain medication, so something worked somewhere. In then end, I had a spinal block with a Cesarian because he was in what the doctor described as the second worse position a baby could be in during labor- posterior, tilted to the side and he was also looking up and back over his shoulder. My husband heard the doctor say 'oh, there's no way he was coming out like that!" Goes to show you that you can plan and prepare, but can't predict or control everything. I think for me personally, that was part of the life lesson this birth experience taught me. I do recommend having a detailed birth plan for every possible situation, because even though you may not want or expect things to go a certain way, they can and often do. that's not to scare you; just be aware and let everyone know your wishes since you will not be able to think when you are in labor. It still may not go exactly as you wanted, but if your husband, midwife/OB, Doula and any other support know what you want it is more likely to happen. I am glad that we had details in the birth plan about how we would like a Cesarian birth to go since I definately couldn't have remembered all that I wanted. Have copies of the birth plan and distribute widely to the nurses (have your doula do that), since there could be a few shift changes if it goes like mine did. :) have your doula make sure they read it! the nurse that was there when I arrived kept saying she'd read it, but from the things she did, it was clear she either didn't or wasn't respecting our wishes. Did I mention that having a supportive husband and doula rocks!? while it didn't go exactly the way I wanted, it was still a good situation considering. My baby is/was wonderfully alert and strong, very healthy. I didn't take any pain medication after the Cesarian either, but did take/use Arnica Montana homeopathy tablets and gel. It was very painful the first couple of days, but not as bad a few days later when I could get out of bed with the baby. car rides were painful for weeks, though. (my husband reminded me of that recently). oh, and I recommend satin sheets so you can slide around in bed instead of using those sore muscles so much. I imagine they'd be useful for recovery from a vaginal delivery too, though can't at this time speak from experience.
If you do end up needing an epidural (and some people do because of exhaustion or other reasons), then save your energy for recovery and dealing with hormonal fluctuations instead of spending it on guilt. :)
My Doula gave some great advice to our pn yoga class- rest and conserve energy starting 2 weeks before your due date. Nap as much as possible and _resist_ the urge to clean the house. Get a cleaning service! It is worth it. If you are well rested, you have more energy and tolerance for pain when in labor. You will not be able to resist all those urges that nature puts out there, (even though by the last month I couldn't be upright for more than a half an hour without my feet looking like a cartoon and feeling like water balloons I just had to cook) but try. I'm glad I didn't resist the urge to get a pedicure the evening before I went into labor, though. :)
I tell people it was the hardest thing I've ever done and the MOST worth it. It won't be easy, but you get a BABY at the end!
Also, people will tell you over and over to get all the help you can after the birth because you will be recovering not only from labor and delivery, but from pregnancy. So, I'll tell you again- get all the help you can for laundry, cooking, cleaning,, running errands and changing diapers. screw the thank you notes until you get a _little_ brain power back- minimum of 6 weeks. I really liked the idea of not having visitors for a long long time, and it worked out to some extent for us. if people want to come by to drop off food or clean the kitchen, then fine, but you shouldn't have to entertain while adjusting to a new human who has been growing inside your body for the last 9 + months and recovering from pregnancy, labor and delivery. It is about you and your new family, not what other people want. That's hard, but I'm glad for the most part we had our privacy. If you cannot avoid visitors, stay in your pajamas. Again, you'll have to resist wanting to run around and do everything. you may feel exhausted, but there is an adrenaline rush going on and you'll think you can take on more than you should.
there are things you may want to re-read while the baby is sleeping or your doing a marathon feeding session. I'm glad I re-read the parts on recovering from the process since it helped to reinforce taking it easy and giving myself a break. It is better for us, our babies and partners if we make a complete recovering instead of glossing over this monumental, life changing event.
Also re read the parts about signs your going into labor soon near your due date when you feel you just don't want to be pregnant any more. -
-
Re: The Bradley Method vs. HypnoBirthing
Thu, October 18, 2007 - 9:13 PM"That's crazy, Ziah... I also did a mix of Birthing from Within and Hypnobirthing- you and I didn't even talk about that."
See, you and me girl...we're like this *fingers crossed" -
-
Re: The Bradley Method vs. HypnoBirthing
Sun, October 21, 2007 - 8:15 AM:) xoxoxo to you! I look forward to having a good sit down drinking herbal tea kind of talk with you about all this soon!
-
-
-
-
Re: The Bradley Method vs. HypnoBirthing
Tue, October 16, 2007 - 3:42 AMI have experience with both methods, and they combine very well. If you are doing a natural childbirth with a partner or husband assisting, go Bradley. If you are not doing a natural birth, or are birthing in a hospital, Hypnobirthing might be more useful to you.
We had two daughters with the Bradley method (which does _not_ make you sign any contracts; some md's are very biased against it it for ignorant reasons) and my husband and I loved it. Not only as a method, but in the classes we learned so much about the way birth and pregnancy work.
-
Re: The Bradley Method vs. HypnoBirthing
Wed, October 17, 2007 - 8:10 PMI want to mention that I haven't talked to any women with a doula that asked for an epidural. Most said that their doula kept them so calm that they never felt afraid of the pain or felt it overwhelm them. Keep moving and voicing the pain/contractions, I did love sitting in a warm tub but it really felt better when I was able to walk around and then squat during contractions (or had the ball nearby to bounce on during contractions..boy I hated that ball until I felt compelled to spend all day bouncing on it and that night went into labor...my body knew something I didn't). I am not saying that it is bad to have an epidural but staying as calm as you can will help you from having a build up of pain. My worst painful contractions were when everyone (nurses, doc, and doula) were all hanging around me and chatting about mundane life like kids b-day parties and schools. I got really ticked and remember thinking "Um, significant point in my life here, I know y'all go through it everyday but I don't". Not sure why it irritated me, seems so silly now, but that was when I started hurting bad.
Also...
Don't go to the hospital until transition, it will delay all the irritating hospital things.
No they DO NOT have to put an IV in your arm when you get there, if there is an emergency they will shove one in, no need to worry about that.
See if you can go on the hospital tour and get the admission form so that you can have it partially filled out when you get there...less irritating questions while you are having contractions. I mean really...my phone number?...why are you asking me that??????
-
-
Re: The Bradley Method vs. HypnoBirthing
Fri, October 19, 2007 - 7:50 AMI agree about the annoying chit-chat! Actually, my doctor warned me about it when I wanted a larger birthing team; she said that it can mean they sometiems get distracted from focusing on the mother, which can be really irritating (this is why I loved having a doctor with four kids of her own).
-
-
Re: The Bradley Method vs. HypnoBirthing
Sun, October 21, 2007 - 7:22 AMI think either method can be fine -- what is most helpful is finding a class in your area where you can meet other mamas-to-be.
The only class in my area is Bradley, so that's what we did. I don't like a lot of things about Bradley ("coaching" for one... birth is a normal event, not something that one needs coaching for!) but I did like how we met other natural birth mamas and daddies!
I had a home birth. My biggest advice would be to avoid the hospital if you can (for as long as you can) - if home birth isn't an option for you, then hire a doula and stay home until transition! Being at home was really the biggest comfort...
Belly Blessings! -
-
Re: The Bradley Method vs. HypnoBirthing
Sun, October 21, 2007 - 8:38 AMI'm curious (not knowing anything about the Bradley Method except what I've read here) what the difference between "coaching" at a birth and the kind of advice/guidance that a doula or midwife offers is? I didn't have a doula, but I'm pretty sure it would have helped a lot, especially with my first birth.
-
Re: The Bradley Method vs. HypnoBirthing
Sun, October 21, 2007 - 12:53 PMI've been biting my tongue here as I have no children yet, but one is on the way. I have been seen at a birthing center here in tucson which uses certified nurse midwives and offers what they call centering classes. According to my midwife, she does not believe in coaching due to the fact that childbirth is well, a natural event and in her experience, coaching can actually hinder progress as she thinks it tends to break peoples focus by trying too hard. She also seemed to think that the bradley method and Lamaze came at a time when women wanted natural childbirth but doctors were hesitant and these methods (especially Lamaze) were intended to quiet the woman down. Since I don't have any experience giving birth yet I don't know wether or not to believe this-this is only info that has been shared with me. What I do know is that this particular birth centers statistics on C-sections is much lower than the national average...about half as much so 10% versus 20%, patients under midwifery care in general had a 19% lower infant mortality rate, a 33% lower neonatal mortality rate, and a 31% decrease in babies with a low birth weight compared to their traditional obsterics counterparts (in a study of 800,000 low risk pregnancies). I also know that when I walk into the birth center-I just feel good. Is is beautiful and oh so not clinical looking. the birth rooms look more like a hotel room and they have a really nice big tub for water births or just relaxing/pain relief while in labor. The birth center is also designed to be less intrusive during childbirth so you can walk around, make as much noise as you'ld like, eat and even have AS MANY people with you as you would like. They also highly encourage and even work with a few doulas here in Tucson on a regular basis. And they encourage you to keep trying to give birth naturally but will support your decision if you need pain relief. I have heard that often at hospitals they keep asking you if you want medication versus just allowing you to ask for it when/if you need it. I have felt so far that birthing ceneters are a nice balance of personal and medical care. Anybody else have experiences with a birthing center. Advice? Is this a good decision?
As for the centering class, it is a newish method of prenatal care, labor, newborn and breastfeeding education all rolled into a class like setting with a few other women and their spouses who share a similar due date. At this birth center, they start you off with individual care and then you have the option to either continue with individual care and take the education class seperately, or join the centering class about midway through pregnancy. I have joined the class and am very happy about it. The other women I met were like minded and extremely supportive. It is nice to talk with someone who is going through what you are going through. And of course as mentioned earlier while in the labor and birthing education they do not teach any particular methods, they do cover several relaxation techniques. Has anybody tried these cenetering classes??? So far I have been very happy with it but I'd like to hear about anybody else that has gone through them. I guess from my limited experience I wonder why anyone would want to give birth at a hospital unless they had to due to a higher risk pregnancy/birth. But since I have not experienced any of this yet, I am eager to hear more about people's experience with both. What worked/what did not work. Even if you get your prenatal care from the birth cenetr here, you still might end up giving birth at the hospital they work with (it is just 2 minutes away and your midwife will still come over and give you care) due to failure to progress, going into labor too early/late, conditions such as preeclampsia etc, etc. So, I want to be prepared for both. -
-
Re: The Bradley Method vs. HypnoBirthing (might be some triggers in here for preggos)
Sun, October 21, 2007 - 2:22 PMSome people HAVE to give birth at a hospital, not because they don't know any better but because the circumstances of their pregnancy dictate it so that their life and their child's life is not endangered. I had a natural birth planned, all ready for no drugs and was sure I'd have a quick labor (my mom's longest out of 4 kids was 5 hours, so I figured I'd go the same way, she pretty much literally walked into the hospital and had a baby. My dad hadn't even got in the elevator after parking the car when I was born). Then I started having pregnancy-induced hypertension at 10 weeks, and at 18 weeks I got sent to a high-risk doctor to check my blood pressure and see if he thought I had impending preeclampsia, and find out the sex... and there were two... so I had to completely scrap my birth plan, switched to the high-risk OB who had experience with multiple pregnancies, and saw the OB every other week until 28 weeks, then every week, and spent a while on bedrest. I made it to 34 weeks and had an emergency c-section when I quite suddenly (within about 2 hours) went from elevated blood pressure to full-blown preeclampsia: pitting edema, proteinuria, blood pressure shot up to 195/115. I was in the OR an hour later and my blood pressure was 215/120 when the anesthesiologist got there (he was a grandpa of twins, nice guy). I had a mag sulf drip for 24 hours after the emergency c-section to keep me from seizing. I never went into labor, never had any contractions, not even a Braxton-Hicks. Never dilated or softened at all. I was freakin' huge though LOL, measured 43 weeks at 34 weeks.
We actually had two hospitals planned for possible delivery depending on when I had them: the first because it had a higher-level NICU and could handle micropreemies in case I delivered before 29 weeks. My OB figured 30 weeks and beyond I could deliver at the hospital he normally worked in, which had a mid-level NICU. It wasn't the birth I wanted, but my boys are both healthy, and I think the c-section saved my life and my boys' lives.
If not for the multiple pregnancy and preeclampsia, I'd have gone to a birthing center and used a midwife. My mom's a PICU nurse and I've heard nothing but rants about doctors all my life LOL. My grandmother told me about giving birth in the 50s, and how she thought she was on a spaceship when she had my mom - she has no recollection of the labor or delivery of any of her 5 children, they used to drug them up that much as a standard practice. Pretty scary. Medical interventions have their place, but many of the ones used as standard practice in childbirth only slow down labor and increase the probability of a c-section.
Anyway I hope that wasn't too scary of a post. Sometimes a hospital and a c-section really are necessary, but I think most of the time they're the doctor trying to preempt a lawsuit.
-
Re: The Bradley Method vs. HypnoBirthing
Sun, October 21, 2007 - 5:09 PMHi Lana!
My first two sons were born at the birth and women's health center. It is a great place. I would still suggest having a doula since you can't be sure of the midwife who will be assisting you or other circumstances (such as many other women in labor at the same time). Often a doula can be very helpful in giving the husband support so he can then assist you in the ways you need.
I don't believe in coaching a woman during birth. Having people you trust to lovingly assist you and being in a place where you feel safe and respected is what most women need to birth naturally.
My third was born at home with a midwife, and that was the most wonderful experience. I know for various reasons that isn't an option for everyone and I think the birth center is a great alternative.
Good luck to you and your growing family :) -
-
Re: The Bradley Method vs. HypnoBirthing
Sun, October 21, 2007 - 10:34 PMIt's neat to hear the many different faces of births ;)... I know when I was pregnant I read birth stories like crazy, and the biggest thing I learned (not that it wasn't a helpful thing to do, mind you) was what my birth WOULDN'T be like... because every birth is so unique. I had two hospital births that really could have happened just as easily at home, but at the time midwifery wasn't covered by provincial healthcare and I was very, very poor, so the hospital it was... I do wish I could have afforded to hire a doula; my best friend and hubby were great, but they didn't have the kind of experience/ideas of what to try that a doula or midwife would've had.
I'm still a little confused about the difference between coaching and the kind of support/advice a midwife or doula would offer during a birth... can anyone enlighten me? Is "coaching" more bossy, the "push now... 1, 2, 3, 4" kind of thing? -
-
Re: The Bradley Method vs. HypnoBirthing
Mon, October 22, 2007 - 6:49 AMAfter all this conversation I think I'm really leaning towards a doula. Thank you for everyone's input!! Any tips on how to sway a very traditional Mexican man on a doula and explain what her purpose is? My husband's feelings are that people have been having kids without classes or assistance for years, so why shouldn't we. I think my mother might think it's a little strange as well. She is very old school and is of the opinion that you go to the hospital, get the epidural and have the baby. How do you explain the purpose of a doula to people that are not necessarily so open minded in that area??
Also, can anyone from Tucson, AZ give me a recommendation on a good doula in the area? -
-
Re: The Bradley Method vs. HypnoBirthing
Mon, October 22, 2007 - 2:35 PMHow much do Doula's cost...or even Midwives? My fiance and I are barely making ends meet right now, financially. I was so sick for the first 6 months I was in bed almost constantly, so I couldn't work. I was used to making over $20 an hour in California before I moved...& he over $30. We both had Medical insurance. We quit our jobs & moved to Provo, Utah not knowing I was pregnant. Out here the pay scale is VERY low & I just barely started working like 10-14 hours a week for very low pay. With all my student loans and what not....he is working two jobs to pay out bills & we are scrapping by.
Because of this situation, we are also on Medicaid.
In all of my appointments so far...it is in and out...no information...nothing....just..."everythign is right where it should be...do you have any questions..." So far my questions have been all about the different sickness symptoms I've had...like migranes...body/muscle pain...nausea....& then the weird acne, hair loss...etc. They have a list of general info. classes to take, but no mention of midwives, doulas, etc.
Also, all the doctors seem to reccomend Epidurals...claiming that there is nothing wrong with them...they just make the process easier...taking away needless suffering.
Does anyone know if Medicaid covers midwived and/or doulas?
How far into the pregnancy are you supposed to start working with them? I'm almost 7 months &have been inactive due to the sickness....
I'M SO CONFUSED....I JUST WANT TO DO WHAT IS SAFEST FOR MY BABY & SECONDLY FOR MYSELF!!!!!!
-
-
Re: The Bradley Method vs. HypnoBirthing
Fri, October 26, 2007 - 11:23 AMTaran, to answer your question, as I understand Bradley (Husband Coached Childbirth) I think the "coach" word really helps define the males role in all this. I didn't really think about it until now, and I went through Bradley twice. I know that it was a term coined back in the 70's when men were not allowed to view or much less be a part of the "main event" of birth (at least in the states....i can't speak for other countries) They all had to wait in the waiting room for their wives and doctors to do their thing and pretty much felt left out of the whole beautiful experience. I think this "coaching" term was a comfortable term for men to feel like a partner and assist their wives (or girlfriends etc) in relaxing as much as possible while tending to their needs (getting water, asking for needs to be met by medical staff when his partner wasn't able to formulate her needs into coherent sentence structure because she is having a contraction!)
This is not to say that Midwives and Doulas are not necessary or needed, but I think it empowers the men to be more intimately involved and connected to their own children and be allowed a window into the "red tent" mysteries that they were forbidden to experience for too long. Hope I was somewhat on target to your question as I understood it. Sorry if it was confusing.
-
-
Re: The Bradley Method vs. HypnoBirthing
Mon, October 22, 2007 - 3:14 PMHi Sandra!!!
Thank you for the reassuring words about your experience. I am definitely into the doula (have been since day one). Especially because Christian and I really don't have anybody else. I know the birth center works with Desert Doulas and I was planning on using one of those ladies. I think they charge around $400? Also Lara: I am on state insurance as well for the time being (will switch soon now that I am married) but the birth center here (they use midwives) takes my insurance!!! I think what I have would be considered medicaid. So, you might want to google utah birth centers and find out. Also, the one that is here is EXTREMELY safe for mother/baby because if for any reason they feel you need more medical attention, they are just down the street from a hospital of which they work with on a regular basis. And the plus to this is you can still keep your midwife but be in a hospital setting and get the medical attention you need! It really seems like the best of both worlds!!! Safety, a home like setting, personal attention etc, etc. Hope that helps. -
-
Re: The Bradley Method vs. HypnoBirthing
Mon, October 22, 2007 - 3:25 PMOhhh, Lara: I forgot to add that much of the statistics that I have seen show that midwifery care can actually be safer for mother/baby than traditional obsterics. Some of the stats I list in one of my previous posts. But, again...I have not gone through the birthing process. this is just the conclusion I have come to due to some of the information I have read and has been told to me. -
-
Re: The Bradley Method vs. HypnoBirthing
Mon, October 22, 2007 - 8:02 PMThanks, I just heard that they use Midwives here, on Medicaid is ok, and they work side by side with the Dr.s in the hospital...no birthing centers.
I'm going to see if I can switch or add or whatever at this point!!!
-
-
-
-
-